The 10 Best NYC Souvenir Shops Travelers Recommend

Jan 07, 2025

The 10 Best NYC Souvenir Shops Travelers Recommend
By Westgate Resorts

The 10 Best NYC Souvenir Shops Travelers Recommend

Discovering the best souvenir shops in New York City is an adventure that combines a love for unique finds with the charm of iconic neighborhoods.

Whether you’re on the hunt for quirky keepsakes, handcrafted treasures, or timeless memorabilia, NYC’s souvenir shops offer something for everyone. Along the way, why not explore fun things to do without spending a dime, like walking through the bustling streets of SoHo or taking in the sights at Rockefeller Center?

Afterward, unwind at relaxing spots in NYC like Bryant Park or the High Line to reflect on your unforgettable shopping experience.

Must-Visit NYC Souvenir Shops

  1. Grand Slam New York – Times Square

  2. New York Transit Museum Gift Shop – Grand Central Terminal

  3. FDNY Fire Zone – Rockefeller Center

  4. Strand Bookstore – Union Square

  5. Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) Design Store – Midtown

  6. NY Gift Shop – Little Italy

  7. Brooklyn Flea – Brooklyn

  8. Economy Candy – Lower East Side

  9. Artists & Fleas – Chelsea Market

  10. Union Square Holiday Market – Seasonal

Exploring the souvenir shops of New York City is more than just a shopping trip – it’s one of the best things to do solo in NYC and a chance to dive into the culture and personality of the city that never sleeps.

The Souvenir Shops You Have to Visit in NYC

From charming mom-and-pop stores tucked away in Greenwich Village to grand emporiums near Times Square, these shops offer a mix of classic NYC flair and hidden gems waiting to be discovered.

Without further ado, here are 10 of the best souvenir shops in NYC that travelers highly recommend.

1 | Grand Slam New York – Times Square | Located in the heart of Times Square, Grand Slam New York is a one-stop shop for classic NYC souvenirs. From “I ❤️ NY” t-shirts and mugs to miniature Statue of Liberty replicas, this store offers a vast selection of affordable items.

  • Why travelers love it: Affordable prices and extensive variety.

  • Pro tip: Shop for discounted bundle deals on t-shirts and magnets.

WHERE: 1557 Broadway, New York, NY 10036 | WHO: (888) 395-0515

VIEW ON GOOGLE MAPS

RELATED ARTICLES:

The 20 Best Food Tours in NYC to Sink Your Teeth Into!

The Ultimate Guide to the Best Pizza in NYC

The Best Things To Do in SoHo, NYC, To Fully Experience It

2 | New York Transit Museum Gift Shop – Grand Central Terminal | For a truly unique memento, visit the New York Transit Museum Store inside Grand Central Terminal. The shop specializes in subway-inspired souvenirs, including maps, vintage transit tokens, and clothing featuring NYC transit designs.

  • Why travelers love it: Unique, high-quality items with a New York flair.

  • Pro tip: Pick up a vintage subway map poster for a chic wall decoration. Consider staying at the nearby Westgate New York Grand Central hotel for comfortable and chic accommodations.

WHERE: 89 E 42nd St, New York, NY 10001 | WHO: (212) 878-0106

VIEW ON GOOGLE MAPS

3 | FDNY Fire Zone – Rockefeller Center | Support the New York City Fire Department while snagging some cool souvenirs at the FDNY Fire Zone near Rockefeller Center. This interactive store offers fire department-themed items like hats, t-shirts, and patches.

  • Why travelers love it: Authentic NYC memorabilia and a chance to support the FDNY.

  • Pro tip: Bring kids for the fire safety demonstrations and hands-on exhibits.

WHERE: 61 W 48th St, New York, NY 10020 | WHO: N/A

VIEW ON GOOGLE MAPS

4 | Strand Bookstore – Union Square | While primarily a bookstore, the Strand Bookstore offers an excellent selection of NYC-themed items, including tote bags, notebooks, and mugs. For literary travelers, it’s a chance to take home a piece of New York’s iconic literary history.

  • Why travelers love it: Quirky and creative items that go beyond traditional souvenirs.

  • Pro tip: Check out their NYC-themed tote bags—they’re a hit among locals and visitors alike.

WHERE: 828 Broadway, New York, NY 10003 | WHO: (212) 473-1452

VIEW ON GOOGLE MAPS

5 | Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) Design Store – Midtown | For art lovers, the MoMA Design Store is a must-visit. This shop features unique, design-forward souvenirs, including art prints, home decor, and books inspired by the Museum of Modern Art's collection.

  • Why travelers love it: Modern, high-quality gifts and souvenirs with a creative edge.

  • Pro tip: Look for exclusive MoMA-branded items that you won’t find anywhere else.

WHERE: 44 W 53rd St, New York, NY 10019 | WHO: (212) 767-1050

VIEW ON GOOGLE MAPS

6 | NY Gift Shop – Little Italy | Nestled in the heart of Little Italy, this charming gift shop offers traditional Italian-American memorabilia alongside classic NYC souvenirs. From NYC snow globes to pasta-shaped keychains, there’s something for everyone.

  • Why travelers love it: A blend of New York and Italian culture in one place.

  • Pro tip: Pair your visit with a meal at one of Little Italy’s iconic restaurants.

WHERE: 106 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013 | WHO: (212) 925-0760

VIEW ON GOOGLE MAPS

7 | Brooklyn Flea | If you’re looking for something truly one-of-a-kind, the Brooklyn Flea is the perfect place to find vintage and artisan-made souvenirs. This popular market offers everything from handmade jewelry to retro NYC postcards.

  • Why travelers love it: Unique, locally crafted souvenirs that stand out.

  • Pro tip: Visit early for the best selection of vintage items.

WHERE: 80 Pearl St, Brooklyn, NY 11201 | WHO: N/A

VIEW ON GOOGLE MAPS

8 | Economy Candy – Lower East Side | For a sweet treat to bring back home, Economy Candy is a nostalgic paradise. This iconic candy store has been around since 1937 and offers a mix of classic candies, NYC-themed chocolates, and vintage sweets.

  • Why travelers love it: Affordable, edible souvenirs with a nostalgic twist.

  • Pro tip: Pick up their NYC-themed candy packs for a fun and tasty gift.

WHERE: 108 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002 | WHO: (212) 254-1531

VIEW ON GOOGLE MAPS

9 | Artists & Fleas – Chelsea Market | Located inside Chelsea Market, Artists & Fleas features a rotating lineup of local artisans and designers selling handmade goods. From custom jewelry and vintage clothing to NYC-themed art prints, this is a great spot for finding high-quality, unique items.

  • Why travelers love it: A chance to meet local makers and support small businesses.

  • Pro tip: Check out their limited-edition NYC-themed prints for a unique wall art piece.

WHERE: 88 10th Ave, New York, NY 10011 | WHO: (917) 488-0044

VIEW ON GOOGLE MAPS

10 | Union Square Holiday Market – Seasonal | If you’re visiting NYC during the holiday season, the Union Square Holiday Market is the ultimate destination for festive and unique souvenirs. This open-air market features local vendors selling handcrafted gifts, ornaments, and seasonal treats.

  • Why travelers love it: A magical holiday atmosphere paired with unique, festive items.

  • Pro tip: Grab a hot cocoa while you browse the stalls to complete your experience.

WHERE: E 14th St, New York, NY 10011 | WHO: N/A

VIEW ON GOOGLE MAPS

Use Our Handy Map to Find Your Way Around!


YOU MAY ALSO LIKE:

Treat Yourself To a Blissful Time of Relaxation at These 8 Best Spas in NYC

The 20 Best Baecation Spots in NYC to Visit This Weekend

The 10 Best Antique Stores NYC Locals Search for Vintage Treasures

Frequently Asked Questions About NYC Souvenir Shopping

Some of the best places to buy souvenirs in New York City include Times Square gift shops, the Union Square Holiday Market, and iconic stores like the Strand Bookstore and the NBC Studio Store at Rockefeller Center. Each of these locations offers unique keepsakes, from traditional "I ❤️ NY" merchandise to handcrafted artisan goods, ensuring there’s something for every taste and budget.

For affordable souvenirs in NYC, visit Chinatown for a mix of cultural items and budget-friendly gifts. Additionally, street vendors around Times Square often sell inexpensive magnets, keychains, and apparel. For unique finds at great prices, check out flea markets like the Chelsea Flea or the Artists & Fleas market in Brooklyn.

Yes, many New York City souvenir shops offer online shopping options. Popular stores like the New York Transit Museum Store, MoMA Design Store, and Strand Bookstore allow you to purchase authentic NYC memorabilia and ship them directly to your home. This is a convenient way to shop if you’re unable to visit the city in person.

Unique souvenirs from NYC include items like vintage subway tokens from the Transit Museum Store, gourmet treats from Chelsea Market, and handmade jewelry or art from local artists at markets like Artists & Fleas. You can also find quirky items, like exclusive Broadway playbills or signed memorabilia from specialty shops.

Yes, there are several souvenir shops near Central Park, including the Columbus Circle shops and kiosks that sell NYC-themed apparel and accessories. The Central Park Conservancy Shop, located within the park, offers exclusive park-related items like maps, books, and eco-friendly products.

The most iconic NYC souvenirs are "I ❤️ NY" T-shirts, mugs, and tote bags. These timeless items are available throughout the city, especially in Times Square and major tourist attractions. Other classics include Statue of Liberty figurines, Empire State Building models, and NY Yankees merchandise.

Yes, many souvenir shops in Times Square are open late, with some operating until midnight or later to cater to tourists. Shops like Grand Slam New York and Gift Mart NYC are excellent options for late-night souvenir shopping.

To find authentic NYC souvenirs, focus on local markets, museum gift shops, and independent stores. Avoid generic items from chain stores and seek out handmade or locally crafted goods. Supporting small businesses and local artisans is also a great way to ensure authenticity.

You can find NYC-themed food souvenirs at places like Eataly, Zabar’s, and Chelsea Market. Items such as bagel-making kits, locally roasted coffee, or jars of New York maple syrup make perfect edible mementos of your trip.

Yes, eco-friendly souvenir options are available at stores like the MoMA Design Store and the Central Park Conservancy Shop. These shops often feature sustainable products, including reusable tote bags, recycled materials, and handmade items that are environmentally conscious.

The Best NYC Souvenir Shops You Have to Visit

From traditional "I ❤️ NY" merchandise to handcrafted artisan goods, NYC offers a wide range of souvenirs to suit every taste and budget.

Whether you're exploring Times Square, browsing local markets, or visiting iconic museums, these 10 top souvenir shops will help you take home a piece of the city that never sleeps.

While you're on your souvenir hunt, why not add a little adventure to your itinerary? The city is packed with fun things to do in NYC, from iconic attractions to unique experiences.

For those who love a touch of mystery, explore some of the city’s haunted places to visit, like the historic Merchant’s House Museum or the eerie hallways of the Algonquin Hotel.

These spooky stops add an unforgettable twist to your trip while offering intriguing stories to bring back home along with your souvenirs.

Plan your visit today and find the perfect NYC memento to remember your trip!

For more guides to exploring New York City, visit our Westgate Resorts Travel Blog.


RELATED ARTICLE:

51 Things to do in NYC

At Westgate Resorts, when you Check-In, there’s a LOT to Check-Out! Your vacation awaits! Start planning your next vacation today or talk with a vacation planner at 888-852-2959 or 407-355-2690.

* Westgate Resorts is in no way affiliated with the attractions featured in this article. Items or places listed are current as of the publishing date of this article. Please call or visit the respective website for the most up-to-date offerings and details.

When You Check-in, There's a Lot to Check Out

Sign up for our newsletter and check-in to great offers, secret stuff, and special events.

Thank You for Signing Up!

Exciting things are headed your way soon!

Read Our Privacy Policy